It’s made for a general viewing audience, so don’t expect any real insight or analysis. It offers a simplistic overview of the shuttle program, but at least it’s pretty. I liked that they included lots of interviews with actual astronauts and NASA staff. I would rather have had them narrate the whole thing.
It’s worth a look, but I have a laundry list of quibbles:
- The clips of the Challenger break-up had explosion sound effects dubbed in. I found that to be disrespectful, cheap, and totally unnecessary. It’s as though the break up of the launch vehicle and death of seven astronauts wouldn’t be enough to hold someone’s attention. This isn’t a World’s Greatest Disasters show, folks.
- The narration was tedious. The voice was an edgy bass that had the cadence and inflection of a movie trailer narrator. “In a world…”, that sort of thing.
- The suggestion that the possible loss of Columbia and astronauts Young and Crippen during STS-1 would be the greatest space tragedy in history… so the loss of the three cosmonauts on the first Salyut mission was/would’ve been less tragic?